STAT 202 Binomial Distribution and Normal Approximation
Lab #9: Binomial Distribution and Normal Approximation
Dr. Clark claims to possess extrasensory perception (ESP). An experiment is conducted in which a person in one room picks one of the integers 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 at random and concentrates on it for one minute. In another room, Dr. Clark identifies the number she believes was picked. The
experiment is done with three trials. After the third trial, the random numbers are compared with Dr. Clark’s predictions.
We can use binomial distributions to analyze the situation. We can compute the probability that the numbers would match by sheer random chance, without any extra help such as ESP.
Question #1: If a person merely guesses, what is the probability of a correct answer? (That is, what is the probability of a success?)
Response: There are 5 integers to choose from within three trials. The probability of a correct answer would be
Question #2: Let X = number of correct guess in three trials. What is the sample space of X?
Question #3: Considering X has a binomial distribution, X ~ B(n, p). What are the values of n and p?
Question #4: What is the probability of each event in the sample space? Write your result in table form where you list the outcomes and the corresponding probabilities. Verify the probabilities sum to one.
P(X = x) You can also use the Binomial Distribution calculator on StatCrunch to verify these values. Go to Stat/Calculator/Binomial, enter the correct values for n and p, and choose a value for example “Prob(X = 2)”.
Question #5: Interpret P(X=2) from the table above. What does this tell you about choosing numbers?
Question #6: Now let’s return to Dr. Clark. She got the correct result twice. Does your work with the related binomial distribution support or refute her claim of ESP? Explain.
We will compare the normal and binomial distributions for various n.
a) Simulate a binomial data set by doing the following: “Data”→ “Simulate” →“Binomial”. Use the following settings:
“n” (insert 50), “p” (insert .08), “columns” (insert 1), and “rows” (insert 150).
b) Compute and .
c) Compute the expected mean,, and standard deviation ,.
d) Create a histogram of your simulated binomial data.
Use the option “Overlay density”, choose Normal, and use the settings for “mean” and “Std.
Dev” which you computed in step c.
Repeat the steps above, replacing “n” with 100, then with 1000. Be sure to use the same bin width on all of your histograms. You do not need to answer Question 7 again for each trial.
Question #7: Compare the 3 histograms. What do you observe as the number of data points, n, increases? Does this correspond with your calculations for step b?
Use StatCrunch to compute the mean and standard deviation of the data in each of the three columns. These are the sample mean values.
Question #8: Examine the mean values. Compare the expected mean values with the sample mean values. Discuss the results. Are some estimates better than others? Is this surprising?
Question #9: Repeat the previous question for standard deviation.